关于“太平有象”第三局的诠正

hzsjy

yjr123先生指出“太平有象”第三局着法有误。其意见完全正确！
着法如下（删除一些变化可作为第四局的变着）：

yjr123

[DhtmlXQ] [DhtmlXQ_ver]www_dpxq_com[/DhtmlXQ_ver] [DhtmlXQ_init]500,350[/DhtmlXQ_init] [DhtmlXQ_comment197]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment197] [DhtmlXQ_comment89]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment89] [DhtmlXQ_result]红胜[/DhtmlXQ_result] [DhtmlXQ_comment31]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment31] [DhtmlXQ_comment438]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment438] [DhtmlXQ_comment119]黑胜定。[/DhtmlXQ_comment119] [DhtmlXQ_comment666]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment666] [DhtmlXQ_comment343]红劣着。[/DhtmlXQ_comment343] [DhtmlXQ_comment167]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment167] [DhtmlXQ_comment342]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment342] [DhtmlXQ_comment0]||第三局:||红先：红车平左黑不吃红中炮劣，红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment0] [DhtmlXQ_comment570]和棋。[/DhtmlXQ_comment570] [DhtmlXQ_comment251]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment251] [DhtmlXQ_remark]沈济英[/DhtmlXQ_remark] [DhtmlXQ_comment726]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment726] [DhtmlXQ_show_move]on[/DhtmlXQ_show_move] [DhtmlXQ_comment774]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment774] [DhtmlXQ_comment279]红胜定。[/DhtmlXQ_comment279] [DhtmlXQ_comment312]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment312] [DhtmlXQ_comment223]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment223] [DhtmlXQ_comment189]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment189] [DhtmlXQ_comment682]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment682] [DhtmlXQ_comment361]臭棋。[/DhtmlXQ_comment361] [DhtmlXQ_comment360]和局。[/DhtmlXQ_comment360] [DhtmlXQ_comment23]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment23] [DhtmlXQ_comment749]||此时接走走象7进5文中已有介绍，即第五局。||此时接走卒6平5即成第二局。[/DhtmlXQ_comment749] [DhtmlXQ_comment747]红劣着。[/DhtmlXQ_comment747] [DhtmlXQ_comment746]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment746] [DhtmlXQ_comment653]红劣着。[/DhtmlXQ_comment653] [DhtmlXQ_comment652]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment652] [DhtmlXQ_movelist]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[/DhtmlXQ_movelist] [DhtmlXQ_comment718]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment718] [DhtmlXQ_comment628]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment628] [DhtmlXQ_comment539]红劣着，使黑逃过一劫。[/DhtmlXQ_comment539] [DhtmlXQ_comment538]红棋胜定。[/DhtmlXQ_comment538] [DhtmlXQ_comment712]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment712] [DhtmlXQ_comment448]红同样胜定。[/DhtmlXQ_comment448] [DhtmlXQ_comment766]和局。[/DhtmlXQ_comment766] [DhtmlXQ_comment674]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment674] [DhtmlXQ_comment267]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment267] [DhtmlXQ_comment496]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment496] [DhtmlXQ_binit]4580999959999999791499999999349962999930325042614799999999675748[/DhtmlXQ_binit] [DhtmlXQ_sound]on[/DhtmlXQ_sound] [DhtmlXQ_comment69]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment69] [DhtmlXQ_comment12]应卒6平5，就是第四局。[/DhtmlXQ_comment12] [DhtmlXQ_comment558]亦和.[/DhtmlXQ_comment558] [DhtmlXQ_comment327]黑如象5进7则是第四局。[/DhtmlXQ_comment327] [DhtmlXQ_comment326]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment326] [DhtmlXQ_author]沈济英(mail:hzshenjiying@163.com)[/DhtmlXQ_author] [DhtmlXQ_comment698]红棋无解，黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment698] [DhtmlXQ_comment555]和.[/DhtmlXQ_comment555] [DhtmlXQ_comment642]红胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment642] [DhtmlXQ_comment235]黑胜。[/DhtmlXQ_comment235] [DhtmlXQ_refer]http%3A//www.dpxq.com/%0D%0Ahttp%3A//www.dpxq.com/hldcg/dhtmlxq/[/DhtmlXQ_refer] [DhtmlXQ_generator] http://www.dpxq.com/ http://www.dpxq.com/bbs/ http://www.dpxq.com/magzine/ http://www.dpxq.com/hldcg/shop/ http://www.dpxq.com/hldcg/chess/ http://www.dpxq.com/hldcg/xqdir/ http://www.dpxq.com/hldcg/search/ http://www.dpxq.com/hldcg/dhtmlxq/ [/DhtmlXQ_generator] [/DhtmlXQ]

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-9-5 8:57:29编辑过]

yjr123

呵呵，大漏着！

yjr123

应该这样：